A waterolor illustration of a dahlia in bloom

Dahlia Doctor Research Library: Dahlia Viruses, Viroids, and How They Spread

A Curated Knowledge Card Collection


Copyright © 2026 by Steve K. Lloyd.
All Rights Reserved.


When Symptoms Are Only Part of the Story


Dahlia growers have long recognized mosaic symptoms as a sign of trouble — distorted leaves, mottled color, stunted growth — without always understanding what is actually happening at the molecular level or why the same plant can look perfectly healthy and still be infected. The research collected here addresses that gap.


This collection brings together thirteen Knowledge Cards on dahlia virus and viroid biology, covering the dahlia mosaic caulimovirus complex, the endogenous viral sequences that complicate molecular diagnosis, the transmission pathways that move pathogens through seed, vegetative stock, sap, and insects, the sampling challenges that make detection unreliable if done wrong, and the viroid risk that sits outside the virus category entirely but affects the same propagation systems. The science in this collection comes primarily from the 2000s and 2010s, a period when molecular tools made it possible to ask — and begin to answer — questions that earlier growers and researchers could only observe from the outside.


Readers of this collection will not find simple prescriptions. They will find the evidence base for why clean stock matters, why symptom-free does not mean virus-free, why the same molecular test can mean different things depending on what it detects, and why pathogens that move through vegetative propagation are fundamentally different from those that blow in on the wind.


About Dahlia Doctor Knowledge Card Collections


Each post in this series presents a curated set of Dahlia Doctor Knowledge Cards organized around a specific research topic. A Knowledge Card summarizes one scientific or technical source using a consistent structure: study system, experimental context, experimental design, key results, mechanistic insight, practical guidance, and why the source matters to dahlia growers and researchers. These summaries represent original interpretive work. They are intended as a research guide, not a substitute for reading the original papers. Each citation title links to a Google Scholar search for that source, opening in a new tab, to help you locate the original publication independently.


Collection Notes


Each Knowledge Card appears once in this collection, placed in the topic cluster where it contributes most directly. Some sources are relevant to more than one cluster; placement reflects primary emphasis rather than exclusive relevance. This collection includes both dahlia virus research and closely related viroid-management research because both affect vegetative stock movement, diagnosis, and sanitation decisions. PSTVd is a viroid, not a virus; it is treated in its own cluster to prevent category confusion.


The Dahlia Mosaic Virus Complex

KC-0278 — Dahlia Mosaic Virus: Molecular Detection and Distribution in Dahlia in the United States


Publication Type

Journal Article


Full Citation

Pappu, H. R., Wyatt, S. D., & Druffel, K. L. (2005). Dahlia mosaic virus: molecular detection and distribution in dahlia in the United States. HortScience, 40(3), 697–699.


Study System

Dahlia; Dahlia mosaic virus (DMV)


Experimental Context

U.S. multi-state survey of dahlia plants conducted in 2003–2004.


Experimental Design

PCR and real-time PCR detection of DMV using ORF4-specific primers; ELISA screening for other viruses.


Key Results

DMV was detected in approximately 85–90% of samples and was present in all surveyed states. Other tested viruses were not detected.


Mechanistic Insight

Molecular detection confirms DMV as a widespread caulimovirus disseminated via propagation material.


Practical Guidance

Implement virus indexing, use virus-free stock, and remove infected plants to limit spread.


Why This Source Matters

This survey established a U.S. baseline for DMV prevalence in cultivated dahlia. The high detection rate across all surveyed states showed that DMV was not simply a local or regional problem. Because dahlias are commonly maintained and distributed through vegetative propagation, the results support the emphasis on clean propagation material, virus screening, and disease-aware stock management as practical and necessary rather than optional.


KC-0098 — Untangling the Taxonomy of Dahlia Mosaic Virus


Publication Type

Journal Article


Full Citation

Geering, A. D. W., McTaggart, A. R., & Teycheney, P. Y. (2022). Untangling the taxonomy of dahlia mosaic virus. Archives of Virology, 167(11), 2325–2329.


Study System

Dahlia mosaic-associated caulimoviruses infecting Dahlia variabilis.


Experimental Context

Comparative viral taxonomy and phylogenetic reanalysis of dahlia mosaic-associated viruses.


Experimental Design

ORF5 sequence alignment, phylogenetic inference, pairwise identity analysis, and recombination testing.


Key Results

DCMV is a clonal lineage within DMV rather than a separate species. The DMV-Portland reference sequence contains a likely sequencing error. The authors proposed updated nomenclature as Caulimovirus dahliae.


Mechanistic Insight

A frameshift or deletion artifact in the DMV-Portland RNase H1 domain likely caused artificial divergence in earlier analyses. Corrected interpretation shows conspecificity between DCMV and DMV.


Practical Guidance

Caution is needed when interpreting dahlia caulimovirus diagnostics, historical isolate names, and claims of multiple active DMV species.


Why This Source Matters

For decades, DCMV and DMV were often treated as separate viruses in the dahlia virus literature. This 2022 reanalysis found that the apparent separation was likely an artifact of a sequencing error in a foundational reference sequence rather than a biological reality. The practical consequence is that older published results distinguishing DCMV from DMV as distinct species should be interpreted cautiously, and that diagnostic claims built on that distinction may not reflect genuine biological difference. This source belongs early in any serious review of dahlia virus biology because it reframes what the earlier literature actually established.


KC-0446 — Partial Molecular Characterization of Dahlia Mosaic Virus and Its Detection by PCR


Publication Type

Journal Article


Full Citation

Nicolaisen, M. (2003). Partial molecular characterization of Dahlia mosaic virus and its detection by PCR. Plant Disease, 87(8), 945–948.


Study System

Dahlia pinnata and Dahlia mosaic virus.


Experimental Context

Molecular characterization of a plant virus and diagnostic assay development.


Experimental Design

PCR amplification, cloning, sequencing, and real-time and conventional PCR assay validation.


Key Results

DMV was confirmed as a Caulimovirus with closest relatives in Figwort mosaic virus and Mirabilis mosaic virus. PCR assays detected DMV with high specificity and sensitivity up to 10⁵ dilution.


Mechanistic Insight

Conserved ORF IV and V regions encode capsid and replication-associated proteins characteristic of caulimoviruses, and serve as reliable targets for molecular detection.


Practical Guidance

PCR diagnostics enable reliable detection of DMV for clean stock development and disease management decisions.


Why This Source Matters

This paper established a basis for later molecular diagnosis of DMV, making it a foundational methods reference for subsequent field surveys and clean-stock programs. The sensitivity and specificity data it reported helped establish PCR as a reliable approach for DMV detection. It belongs in this collection because it shows where the diagnostic capability came from, not just that the capability exists.


KC-0121 — Biological Studies of Three Caulimoviruses Associated With Dahlia (Dahlia variabilis)


Publication Type

Journal Article


Full Citation

Eid, S., & Pappu, H. R. (2014). Biological studies of three caulimoviruses associated with dahlia (Dahlia variabilis). Canadian Journal of Plant Pathology, 36(1), 110–115.


Study System

Dahlia variabilis.


Experimental Context

Caulimovirus infection and symptom expression in dahlias, including host-range testing, symptom assessment, and transmission assays.


Experimental Design

Biological characterization of three caulimovirus isolates via host-range testing, symptom assessment, and mechanical and graft transmission assays.


Key Results

Three distinct caulimovirus isolates differed in symptom severity and host range. Mechanical and graft transmission were confirmed.


Mechanistic Insight

Biological variation among caulimoviruses influences disease expression and spread in dahlias, meaning that which isolate is present matters for what growers observe.


Practical Guidance

Use virus-indexed clean stock; control mechanical transmission; monitor for mixed infections.


Why This Source Matters

This paper showed that the caulimoviruses associated with dahlia mosaic can differ biologically, producing different symptom profiles and host-range patterns. The confirmation of mechanical and graft transmission established propagation-relevant routes. It is the biological-characterization foundation that complements the molecular and survey work in this cluster.


KC-0714 — Incidence of Multiple and Distinct Species of Caulimoviruses in Dahlia (Dahlia variabilis)


Publication Type

Peer-reviewed Journal Article


Full Citation

Eid, S., Druffel, K. L., Saar, D. E., & Pappu, H. R. (2009). Incidence of multiple and distinct species of caulimoviruses in dahlia (Dahlia variabilis). HortScience, 44(5), 1498–1500.


Study System

Cultivated Dahlia variabilis.


Experimental Context

Field survey of symptomatic and asymptomatic plants in display gardens, 2007–2008.


Experimental Design

PCR-based detection using virus-specific primers; cloning and sequencing of amplicons; 213 samples tested.


Key Results

DMV-D10 was detected in 94% of samples; DCMV in 48.5%; DMV in 23%. Mixed infections were common. Only 2% of samples tested negative for all three targets. Infection was not consistently correlated with symptoms.


Mechanistic Insight

DMV-D10 exists as an endogenous plant pararetroviral sequence. DCMV and DMV appear episomal. Asymptomatic and mixed infections complicate diagnosis.


Practical Guidance

PCR testing is required for accurate detection. Screen and propagate virus-free stock. Management must account for the possibility of multiple caulimoviruses in a single plant.


Why This Source Matters

This field survey produced some of the most striking detection data in the dahlia virus literature: DMV-D10 was detected in 94% of samples, DCMV in nearly half, DMV in 23%, and only 2% of samples tested negative for all three targets. Just as important, detection did not consistently match visible symptoms. Read alongside KC-0081, this paper also shows why the word "detected" must be used carefully when one of the most common signals reflects an endogenous genomic element rather than a straightforward active infection.


Endogenous Viral Sequences and Diagnostic Confusion

KC-0081 — A New and Distinct Species in the Genus Caulimovirus Exists as an Endogenous Plant Pararetroviral Sequence in Its Host, Dahlia variabilis


Publication Type

Experimental Research Article


Full Citation

Pahalawatta, V., Druffel, K., & Pappu, H. (2008). A new and distinct species in the genus Caulimovirus exists as an endogenous plant pararetroviral sequence in its host, Dahlia variabilis. Virology, 376(2), 253–257.


Study System

Dahlia variabilis and Dahlia mosaic caulimovirus-D10.


Experimental Context

A distinct caulimovirus associated with dahlia mosaic had previously been detected at high frequency in dahlia samples, in multiple plant parts, in tissue-culture-derived plants, and in seed-transmitted progeny. These observations indicated possible integration of viral sequences into the dahlia genome.


Experimental Design

Total genomic DNA was extracted from dahlia seedlings, seed coats, embryos, and roots. Southern blot hybridization used labeled probes representing viral open reading frames. Fluorescent in situ hybridization used labeled probes from viral ORFs I and VI on metaphase chromosomes from dahlia root tips. DMV-Portland probes were used for comparison.


Key Results

The DMV-D10 genome was 7046 bp with caulimovirus-like organization, but lacked an aphid transmission factor and had a truncated coat protein. Phylogenetic analysis placed DMV-D10 as a distinct species within Caulimovirus. Southern blot hybridization detected DMV-D10 sequences in dahlia genomic DNA at high molecular weights, indicating chromosomal rather than episomal location. Fluorescent in situ hybridization localized DMV-D10 sequences to several dahlia chromosomes. DMV-Portland probes did not hybridize under the same conditions.


Mechanistic Insight

The data support DMV-D10 as an endogenous plant pararetroviral sequence integrated into the dahlia genome. Whether it also exists as an episomal element in infected plants remained unresolved. Absence of an aphid transmission factor, a truncated coat protein, unsuccessful mechanical transmission, and vertical inheritance are consistent with a primarily endogenous status.


Practical Guidance

Meristem tip culture and virus-free stock approaches may not be effective when viral genomes are integrated into the host genome. Knowledge of the environmental conditions that trigger symptom development will be essential for management under such circumstances.


Why This Source Matters

This paper explains why DMV-D10 appeared in earlier surveys across tissue-culture plants, seedlings, and seed coats despite attempts to eliminate it. The evidence indicated that DMV-D10 was present as an integrated genomic sequence, not simply as a conventional episomal virus. That finding reframes what a positive PCR result for DMV-D10 actually means: it may indicate endogenous sequence presence rather than active infection. For diagnosticians, the implication is that clean-stock protocols designed for episomal viruses do not necessarily address integrated sequences, and that the relationship between detection, infection, and disease is more complicated in this system than in most.


KC-0238 — Genetic Diversity Among Endogenous Plant Pararetroviral Sequences from Geographically Diverse Sources of Dahlia (Dahlia spp.)


Publication Type

Conference Presentation


Full Citation

Almeyda, C. V., Druffel, K. L., Eid, S. G., & Pappu, H. (2012, March). Genetic diversity among endogenous plant pararetroviral sequences from geographically diverse sources of dahlia (Dahlia spp.). In Washington State University Academic Showcase.


Study System

Dahlia variabilis; Dahlia rupicola.


Experimental Context

Molecular population genetics of endogenous caulimovirus-related sequences across cultivated and wild dahlia populations.


Experimental Design

Full-length endogenous pararetroviral sequence genomes (n=7) were sequenced from cultivated and wild dahlias. Phylogenetic, population genetics, and recombination analyses used MEGA5, DnaSP, SNAP, and RDP3.


Key Results

All isolates formed a single clade with no geographic or host-type clustering. The replicase region showed the highest nucleotide diversity. All open reading frames were under strong negative selection. Multiple recombination events were detected.


Mechanistic Insight

Genetic diversity is driven by mutation and recombination during reverse transcription, with strong purifying selection maintaining open reading frame integrity. Geographic origin does not predict sequence divergence.


Practical Guidance

Endogenous pararetroviral sequence presence reflects genomic integration rather than active infection. Geographic origin of dahlia material does not predict whether these sequences will be present or absent.


Why This Source Matters

This study extended the endogenous sequence story across cultivated and wild dahlia populations from multiple geographic sources and found patterns more consistent with long-term endogenous genomic elements than with simple recent spread of a circulating pathogen. The lack of geographic clustering, the strong purifying selection on all open reading frames, and the presence of recombination events all point to long-term host integration rather than recent horizontal transmission. The key diagnostic implication, stated directly in the KC, is that detection of these sequences by DNA-based molecular tests does not equal active infection, and that geographic source of the plant material does not change that interpretation.


Transmission Pathways: Stock, Seed, Sap, and Insects

KC-0449 — Seed Transmission of Dahlia Mosaic Virus in Dahlia pinnata


Publication Type

Journal Article


Full Citation

Pahalawatta, V., Druffel, K., & Pappu, H. R. (2007). Seed transmission of Dahlia mosaic virus in Dahlia pinnata. Plant Disease, 91(1), 88–91.


Study System

Dahlia pinnata; Dahlia mosaic virus (Caulimovirus).


Experimental Context

Investigation of seedborne and seed transmission of DMV under aphid-free conditions.


Experimental Design

PCR detection of virus in seed parts, seedlings, greenhouse grow-outs, and pollen from infected plants.


Key Results

DMV was detected in cotyledons and in all tested seedlings. Detection in seed coats was rare. Symptom expression in infected seedlings was delayed. Pollen from infected plants tested PCR-positive.


Mechanistic Insight

Virus is localized primarily in cotyledons, enabling true seed transmission from infected parent to offspring. Asymptomatic early infection contributes to pathogen spread without visible warning.


Practical Guidance

Use virus-free seed and vegetative propagation stock. Molecular testing is required for early detection in seedlings because symptoms are delayed.


Why This Source Matters

Before this study, vegetative propagation was the main recognized route of DMV movement. This paper showed that DMV can also move through seed, with virus detected in cotyledons of tested seedlings from infected parents and in pollen from infected plants. Symptom expression in infected seedlings was delayed, meaning spread through seed could occur without visible early warning. For breeders working with seed from dahlia stock of uncertain health status, and for growers who assume that seed-raised plants start clean, this is essential background.


KC-0600 — First Record of Dahlia Mosaic Virus in Iraq on Dahlia (Dahlia pinnata)


Publication Type

Journal Article


Full Citation

Abduljalil, Z. A., Kassim, N. A., & Duhoky, M. M. S. (2019). First record of Dahlia mosaic virus in Iraq on Dahlia (Dahlia pinnata). Journal of Duhok University, 22(2), 113–120.


Study System

Dahlia pinnata; indicator plant species.


Experimental Context

Field survey and greenhouse diagnostics following observation of mosaic symptoms on dahlia in Iraq.


Experimental Design

PCR-based virus detection; mechanical and aphid transmission assays.


Key Results

Dahlia mosaic virus was detected in leaves and tubers. The virus was mechanically transmissible. Aphid transmission was confirmed with Myzus persicae and Aphis fabae as vectors.


Mechanistic Insight

DMV ORF1 encodes a movement protein enabling systemic infection and vector-mediated transmission. Tuber involvement confirms pathogen access to vegetative propagation material.


Practical Guidance

Virus indexing and aphid control are important in vegetative propagation systems. Detection in tubers means infected propagation material can carry the virus from one season or location to the next.


Why This Source Matters

This paper is the only source in this collection providing direct experimental evidence of aphid vector species for DMV in dahlia, with Myzus persicae and Aphis fabae confirmed as vectors. The detection of virus in tubers is equally important because it shows that infected vegetative propagation material can carry DMV across seasons and locations.


KC-0616 — Hygiene Protocol for Dahlia PSTVd


Publication Type

Technical Protocol / Extension Report


Full Citation

van Leeuwen, P. J. (2014). Hygiëneprotocol Dahlia PSTVd [Hygiene protocol for dahlia PSTVd]. Praktijkonderzoek Plant & Omgeving, Sector Bollen, bomen & fruit.


Study System

Dahlia (vegetative propagation and field cultivation systems).


Experimental Context

Disease prevention and hygiene management in dahlia propagation and field production, focused on preventing spread of Potato spindle tuber viroid (PSTVd) within and between plant lots.


Experimental Design

Literature review and synthesis of transmission routes and hygiene implications, resulting in a structured protocol document.


Key Results

Vegetative propagation is the primary risk factor for PSTVd persistence and spread in dahlia. Mechanical transmission via sap transfer on hands, tools, and equipment during handling is a confirmed route. Other transmission routes remain unconfirmed.


Mechanistic Insight

Mechanical transmission occurs via sap contact during normal handling and propagation operations. Vegetative propagation perpetuates infection from mother plants to all daughter material derived from them.


Practical Guidance

Implement strict hygiene protocols including glove use, tool disinfection between plants, physical separation of suspect lots, dedicated equipment and clothing for infected material, and use of tested disease-free propagation stock.


Why This Source Matters

This protocol document is placed in the transmission cluster rather than the viroid cluster because its primary contribution is not to viroid biology but to the interruption of transmission. The logic it applies — controlling sap transfer on hands, tools, and equipment and protecting the propagation chain — also helps explain why hygiene matters across vegetatively propagated pathogen risks, even though this protocol is specifically about PSTVd. It provides the bridge between the biological evidence in this collection and the sanitation decisions that follow from it.


Symptoms, Sampling, and Diagnosis

KC-0690 — Distribution of Tomato Spotted Wilt Virus in Dahlia Plants


Publication Type

Original Research Article


Full Citation

Asano, S., Hirayama, Y., & Matsushita, Y. (2017). Distribution of Tomato spotted wilt virus in dahlia plants. Letters in Applied Microbiology, 64(4), 297–303.


Study System

Dahlia variabilis (cultivar Kokucho) infected with Tomato spotted wilt virus (TSWV).


Experimental Context

Investigation of the spatial distribution of TSWV within vegetative and storage tissues of dahlia to identify optimal diagnostic sampling regions.


Experimental Design

Microtissue direct RT-PCR and tissue blot immunoassay applied to defined regions of compound leaves, stems at different growth stages, and bulb transverse sections. Detection rates were quantified and bulb infection was scored on a 0–3 scale.


Key Results

TSWV was unevenly distributed throughout the plant. Detection rates were highest in petioles and middle stem sections. Upper stem detection increased at flowering. Bulb infection was highly heterogeneous, with many sections showing less than one-third infected area. Some apical cuttings from infected source plants tested virus-free.


Mechanistic Insight

TSWV movement is phloem-associated with restricted spread into adjacent tissues. Distribution within the plant is influenced by growth stage and source-to-sink transport dynamics. These factors produce heterogeneous viral localization at the tissue level.


Practical Guidance

Sample middle stem sections or petiole and vein tissue of compound leaves for reliable TSWV detection. Avoid bulb tissue for diagnostics. Tissue selection determines whether a test can detect the pathogen at all.


Why This Source Matters

This study provides experimental evidence that virus distribution within a plant is not uniform, and that sampling location determines whether a test can detect the pathogen at all. The finding that some apical cuttings from infected source plants tested virus-free is particularly significant. It shows that TSWV distribution can be uneven enough that propagation tissue may not always carry the virus, while also warning that test results depend heavily on which tissue is sampled. The practical lesson is not that cuttings are automatically safe or unsafe, but that diagnostic sampling and propagation decisions must account for heterogeneous virus distribution within the plant.


PSTVd as a Dahlia Viroid Risk

KC-0442 — PSTVd (Potato Spindle Tuber Viroid) in Dahlia: Desk Study


Publication Type

Research Report


Full Citation

van Leeuwen, P. J. (2014). PSTVd (aardappelspindelknolviroïde) in dahlia: Deskstudie [PSTVd (potato spindle tuber viroid) in dahlia: Desk study]. Praktijkonderzoek Plant & Omgeving.


Study System

Dahlia (with comparative host systems).


Experimental Context

Quarantine viroid risk assessment following first detection of PSTVd in dahlia.


Experimental Design

Literature review and synthesis of diagnostic findings, host range, transmission routes, and hygiene implications across PSTVd-affected host systems.


Key Results

Dahlia can harbor PSTVd without producing symptoms. Vegetative propagation is the primary risk for pathogen persistence and spread. Mechanical transmission via sap is plausible. Other transmission routes remain unconfirmed in dahlia.


Mechanistic Insight

PSTVd is a stable, small RNA pathogen with symptom-variable expression that relies on host replication machinery and sap-mediated spread. Its behavior in dahlia mirrors its behavior in other susceptible hosts.


Practical Guidance

Use only clean, tested propagation material. Implement hygiene protocols covering hands, tools, and equipment. Clean starting material, tool hygiene, and strict handling protocols are the core available management approach.


Why This Source Matters

This desk study was produced in response to the first confirmed detection of PSTVd in dahlia, a quarantine event with immediate implications for producers operating in regulated markets. It synthesized what was known about PSTVd biology and behavior in other hosts and applied it to the dahlia context at a point when dahlia-specific data were scarce. Its value in this collection is as a clear-eyed statement of what was known and what was not at that moment: infection is asymptomatic, vegetative propagation is the primary risk, and clean starting material combined with tool hygiene is the core available management approach.


KC-0514 — Development of a Diagnostic Test for PSTVd in Dahlia


Publication Type

Technical Research Report


Full Citation

van Leeuwen, P. J., Trompert, J. P. T., Lemmers, M. E. C., Verbeek, M., & Meekes, E. T. M. (2016). Toetsontwikkeling PSTVd in dahlia [Development of a diagnostic test for PSTVd in dahlia]. Praktijkonderzoek Plant & Omgeving, onderdeel van Wageningen UR Business Unit Bloembollen, Boomkwekerij en Fruit.


Study System

Dahlia cultivars; PSTVd in tomato inoculum.


Experimental Context

Greenhouse quarantine context following PSTVd detection in dahlia, requiring development of a reliable detection protocol for routine screening.


Experimental Design

Seasonal infection trials; RNA extraction and assay comparison across tissue types and time points post-inoculation.


Key Results

PSTVd is symptomless in dahlia. The viroid was not reliably detectable until approximately 8 weeks post-infection. Infection success was higher in spring trials. The viroid was present in multiple tissue types.


Mechanistic Insight

Environmental conditions and RNA extraction quality both influence viroid detectability. The absence of symptoms means that diagnostic timing and tissue selection are the only available guides to test reliability.


Practical Guidance

Leaf-based qRT-PCR is suitable for routine PSTVd testing in dahlia after a sufficient post-infection interval. Testing too early — before approximately 8 weeks post-infection — risks false-negative results.


Why This Source Matters

Where KC-0442 established the biological and regulatory context for PSTVd in dahlia, this paper established the technical infrastructure for testing for it reliably. The finding that PSTVd was not reliably detectable in dahlia until approximately 8 weeks post-infection has direct consequences for screening programs: a plant tested too early can appear clean and still be infected. The seasonal variation in infection success and the multi-tissue distribution findings add further nuance to what a negative test result can and cannot support. This paper closes the arc from recognition of the risk through understanding of the pathogen to practical detection — and ends, appropriately, with a caution about the limits of the test itself.


AI Collaboration Transparency


The Knowledge Card summaries in this collection were developed from the Dahlia Doctor research archive and checked against available source records during editorial preparation. AI tools assisted with retrieval, formatting, comparison, and assembly of the collection. All curatorial decisions — including source selection, topic organization, interpretation, and final editorial framing — were made by the author. 


Return to Articles